C. Get the stories.
1. Find out more about the nature and
character of these communities by moving from facts to stories.
Once you get to know people, ask about some of their own stories
in relation to this community. A portrait needs more than facts.
It requires people and the story as told from their perspective.
One might ask:
2. Getting people to speak about their
own experience requires a certain amount of trust and confidence.
Be yourself. Introduce yourself. Talk about the Pluralism Project
and your summer work. Be simple and straightforward about who
you are and why you are there.
You will learn a lot informally over
coffee or tea in the soal hail of the temple or mosque. :150 will
want to fix some times for conversations that might more properly
called interviews. You are the best judge of how much you will
be able to ask. Take notes. At least key phrases and words that
will allow you to reconsruct the conversation after you leave.
Depending on the situation, you might well ask to use a tape recorder,
which frees you for a more spontaneous encounter. For many people,
taping is not intrusive and both of you will forget about the
tape recorder after the first minute. A few people may be apprehensive
about taping.
E. Methodology.
This summer Brigit McCallum has prepared
a set of readings of reflections on the nature of fieldwork and
qualitative interviewing. Spend some time reading these pieces
before you go, and bring the Project notebook along with you.
1. Look at bulletin boards for notices
of activites. Collect pamphlets, schedules, publications. If they
cost money, keep a receipt and the project will reimburse you.
Use your judgement, but do not miss the ocasion to collect and
purchase whatever is related to our work. The humble pamphlet
or flyer is an extremely important document for researcher in
popular and as yet undocumented religious life. If you do not
come home with half a suitcase full of pamphlets, I will be disappointed.
2. Talk to as wide a range of people
as possible. Do not get all your information from leaders or priests,
but meet participants, lay people, young and old, women and men.
3. You will find your own style and
way of questioning by trial and error. There is no one correct
method, but you should care that your questions don't imply or
include a particular answer. For example, ask, "Why did you
have trouble getting a zoning variance?" rather than "Did
you have trouble getting a zoning variance because the neighbors
were concerned about traffic?"
4. Set aside some time as soon as you
leave the temple or mosque to write as full and extensive an account
as you can of your visit, recording what you saw, what impressed
you, what puzzled you, and what you learned. Be as descriptive
as your boldest prose will stretch. The more extensive your daily
digest of field notes, the easier it will be to write up a final
report.
5. Take photographs if you have a camera.
Slides are most verstile, so take at least some slides. We will
buy the film and processing for those photos that pertain to the
Project. Keep receipts. If you photograph each temple or mosque,
each meditation center or gurudwara, just once from the outside,
we will have quite a collection. Don't be deterred by the fact
that many of the buildings may be plain and uninteresting from
the outside. A mosque in a former one story office building is
also important. If you take any interior photographs, which would
also be wonderful, be certain to ask first if it is acceptable.
6. The work that all of us will be engaged in for the Pluralism Project builds upon our academic work here at Harvard and yet challenges us to learn what we need to know, not only by reading, but by fieldwork. For almost everyone, this is ditficult at times. It means putting oneself in new situations, introducing oneself to strangers, being in the role of stranger in a community that is not one's own. It is immensely rewarding, but you will need from time to time to spend a day at home simply writing, reading, and reflectirng.
7. If there are situations in which
you feel unsafe, take a friend along or don't go.
F. General Etiquette
1. In this project you are not just
you. You are a representative of Harvard University and associated
with a research project administered through the Committee on
the Study of Religion and the Office of Sponsored Research. This
means, in a word, be on your best behaviour. Identify yourself
when you call or visit. If "I'm from Harvard University,"
seems a bit heavy handed or off-putting for the casual encounter,
merely identifying yourself as a university student or as affiliated
with a university research project is probably enough. If you
sit down in a more or less formal situation to interview someone,
however, you should give a full description of what the project
is about. I am quite sure that desribing the Pluralism Project
will itself elicit many responses from the people you speak with
and that you will find it to be an advantage in opening doors.
2. Respect the atmosphere of ritual
or worship. When you visit a community involved in worship, meditation,
prayers, or festivities, don't take out pen and paper unless you
have made quite certain that it would not be intrusive or rude.
Use this as an occasion to sharpen your powers of sheer observation.
If the atmosphere permits, making a few notes as you visit a place
will permit you to reall more accurately when you sit down later
to write field notes.
G. Get the big picture, the community
picture.
1. Visit a hospital and speak with
an administrator to find out about chaplaincy. Are there chaplains
of many faiths affiliated with the hospital? How does the hospital
deal with special needs of people of various faith communities
in times of crisis? Special food needs, for instance, for Hindus
or Muslims.
2. Visit a school principal or the
school superintendent, even a school teacher. How is the religious
diversity of the student body approached in the school system.
Are various holidays discussed, with this being the opportunity
for education?. Do teachers have some training in the religious
traditions of the students they teach? Is religion excluded completely,
or included? Has their been discussion of teaching about various
religious traditions in the school system?
3. Visit city hall and speak with the
mayor or someone in the mayor's office about the way in which
the city has dealt with the new religious diversity of the population.
Are there particular issues that have come up? Are there substantaal
changes in the city's population make-up as reflected in the recent
census? Are there multicultural projects or programs sponsored
by the city?
4. Visit with the pastors of several
churches. In what ways do relations with people of other faiths
come up in the church context, either in terms of education or
outreach?
5. Visit the council of churches and/or
the association of synagogues. Is there a local chapter of the
National Council of Christians and Jews? Is it increasingly concerned
with wider interfaith issues? Is there a local interfaith association.
Find out what is happening organizationally. -
III. PROJECT PROCEDURES
1. Arrange with Susan Shueeker and
Nancy Colbert before you leave how you wish to be paid and when.
It is essential that you leave a summer address with Susan.
2. You will be reimbursed for xeroxing,
books, pamphlets, calendars, film and film processing. It is essential,
however, that you carelully save all receipts in order to be reimbursed.
Turn them in to Susan Shumaker, who will give them to Nancy Colbert
for accounting.
3. Since there are so many short-term
reserchers this summer, we have to find ways of keeping transportation
costs under controL Transportation to and from the place of work
will be allocated to (a) researchers working somewhere other than
their "home" and b) rearchers working more than one
month. If air travel is involved see Susan or Diana about arrangements.
All of you will be reimbursed for local transportation within
the realm of reason. If it is for gas, you must get and save receipts.
If you get public transportation tickets, bus tickets, subway
tickets, etc. find a way of documenting the expenditure through
receipts. The Project is not able to rent cars for local work.
4. If there is an opportunity to visit
a retreat center, go to a summer camp for kids, or participate
in some other special event that costs something reasonable, keep
track of expeditures as long as they are not extravagant. If you
have a question, call us.
5. Let us know where you are staying
throughout the time you are working on the Project.
6. Sign the University Reserch Prartices
document before you go.
1. Space - Mariah
Describe the space in which the community
gather. Describe the building, both outside and inside. In what
kind of room does the community gather for worship, meditation;
or prayer? What is distinctive about this space? What is its focal
point or orientation? Is there the sense of a "center"?
Many centers? Are there objects, images, or other indicators of
the center? How is the room decorated, adorned, or made special
in some way? Are there other community rooms besides that in which
people gather for worship? What are they for? How are they used?
What do they tell us about the community?
2. Time - Kerensa
When does the community gather? Daily?
Many times a day? Weekly? Monthly? On which particular days? Are
there particular times when most people come? Are there other
times when a smaller community gathers or when individuals come?
What is the calendar of this community? What are the most important
festivals or holy days of the year in this community? What do
the publications of the community - pamphlets, calendars, newsletters,
schedules - tell us about its regular atttivities?
3. Ritual - Andrea
What does the community do when it
gathers together? How would you describe the ritual life of the
community? What are the patterns of ritual practice: singing,
chanting, prayer, worship, processions, sermons, offerings, meditation,
martial arts? What vestments or special garb are worn, if any?
What prominent symbols are used? Who seems to take leadership
roles in rituals? Are there particular ritual acts that mark entry
into the sacred space? Are there particular ritual acts that indicate
the sacredness of symbols or images? Are there particular ritual
acts that seem to establish the bonding of the community? What
seems to be the relation between the individual and community
as ritually expressed? [How did you respond to the ritual? How
did you feel as a "participant observer" here?]
4. Composition of Community - Mariah
Who comes? What is the make-up of those
who participate in this center or community in terms of neighborhood,
race, ethnic group, background, age? Is it relatively homogenous?
Mixed? What is the range of diversity? How many people are there
in this community? How many members? How many regular participants?
How many occasional "festival" participants? Who actually
participates? Who seem to be the principal actors? Are they priests?
laypeople? teachers? What about the presence and role of children,
if any? How would you describe the gathered community? Is it friendly?
approachable? [Do you feel comfortable being there?]
5. Teachings or "Beliefs"
- Martha
Is there a definite body of teaching
or belief associated with this community? If so, what does the
community "believe?" What are the principal tenets?
Does it share a set of basic beliefs with other groups or with
a larger movement? What elements in its teachings are most often
emphasized? How important is the teaching or belief system to
the community? Can you tell how wide a variance in beliefs is
permitted? How are beliefs or teachings communicated in the ritual
life of the community? If teachings or beliefs do not seem to
be central, can you discern what it is that holds the community
together? [What do you find most compelling, most inspiring,
most alien in the teachings or beliefs as presented?]
6. Authoritative Texts or Teachers
- Emily
What seems to constitute religious
authority in this community? Are there particular writings, sacred
or otherwise, that the community emphasizes and uses? Is there
a functional canon? Do they take these writings or texts available
on the premises? How are scriptures or other writings used in
the context of community worship, daily practice, either personal
or communal? Is there instruction in these scriptures or writings?
Is there a "canon within the canon," that is a special
part of the teaching or writing that seems even more authoritative?
Did you have any particular resp6nse to the structure of authority
in the community?]
7. History and Trajectory - Karla
What is the history of this particular
community? When was it formed? By whom? Why? What is its relation
to the broader religious tradition of which it is a part? With
what strand of the tradition is it affiliated? Is it sectian or
ecumenical? ethnic or international? Has the community written
a history of itself? Are there ways in which the community celebrates
or remembers its own history? Might there be significant differences
between what people in the community say about its history and
what outside historians, present or future, might say? What do
the people in the movement say about its future? What are their
immediate and long term goals and hopes? [What is your own assessment
of the future of this community?]
8. Relation to Wider Community - Kerensa
Is there an articulated sense of the relation of this particular religious community to the urban, suburban, or rural area of which it is a part? Is there a program of outreach into the wider community? Are civic and social problems discussed? Are national and global problems discussed? Are they seen to be integrally related to the religious life of the community? Are there action programs in the community to address these problems? What is the relationship of this community to other religious communities in the area - especially to those of other traditions? Is there much consciousness of other faiths? How is it expressed? (What points of connection do you see between a religious community you already know or belong to and this one?)